Prior to heading to MW2007, I sat down with some of the WACTAC teens to discuss Myspace, Facebook and social networking in general. I thought I had a good handle on things (since I have, in fact, used Myspace). I figured a talk with the experts would fill in any gaps I was missing.
Download Social Networking Discussion MP3
Much of what I learned is interwoven in the notes I prepared for our workshop at MW2007. Here are some of the highlights, according to WACTAC:
- Myspace is old news
- Facebook is where all the cool kids are
- Some kids don’t even use email these days, sticking to myspace or facebook
- Kids consume a lot of media, therefore use a lot of media
- When multiple people add content to social accounts for institutions, let people know who’s doing the update
- Don’t use a different account for different departments
- Make groups and encourage people to join
- Make use of bulletins and notes
- Keep things up to date, nothing is worse than an out of date profile or events
The big thing that I took away from our chat was that it seems that Facebook is becoming the favorite among more technically savvy users. It seems due to the more refined design and permissions system that it enforces. So all the web designers who hate myspace because it is ugly can rejoice; smart users are shying away. Facebook is also more strict about who can create and hold an account. I heard from some people at MW2007 that their attempts to create a “person” for their institution were rebuffed, and they were forced to create a group instead. While that doesn’t fit with the paradigm that has happened within other social Web 2.0 applications, it does seem to be one that is more sustainable for users in the long run.
I just created a Walker Art Center group on Facebook. The acebook APIs seem interesting, and something Myspace does not offer to my knowledge. It is something I might play around with in the future.
Please note that this is a rough cut and basically unedited. I am adhering to the “quick and dirty” principles we discussed in our workshop. A big thanks to the teens that participated in the discussion:
- Willy Schwartz
- Basanti Miller
- Mark Severson
- Ricardo Ortiz-Vasquez
Also thanks to Witt Siasoco and Megan Leafblad for setting the discussion up.
Facebook may be more popular with the kids, but it doesn’t seem to suit the purpose of an organisation like yours as much as MySpace, which seems to have a nicer interface.
What do you think?
Comment by Jim Richardson — 5/21/2007 @ 3:27 pm
We are still looking into how to most effectively use MySpace and facebook. We do know that it takes a lot of work, and it is just one more place that we don’t have time to always manage correctly. Neither myspace or facebook provides any easy way to input events. How about an iCal import?
In terms of interface, I rather like Facebook compared to MySpace, and I think the kids agreed. Myspace allows us to be a person, which is nice, but I think that a group set up properly in Facebook is probably going to hit more people that are really interested.
Comment by Justin Heideman — 5/24/2007 @ 10:59 am
Going back to MySpace, I’ve been looking at pages created by arts venues around the world, and so many are really terrible ( http://www.myspace.com/centrepompidou for example ) but in order to create a good up to date MySpace page is like a full time job.
My guess is that lots of arts organisation with limited budget and staff, create a page then don’t have the time or the money to make it work for them, which then probably alienates the young people it is meant to attract.
Comment by Jim Richardson — 5/25/2007 @ 3:04 pm
[…] lines right up with what I found when I talked to some of the WACTAC teens a few months ago. I’m still contemplating what this means for a museum, or any institution […]
Pingback by New Media Initiatives Blog » Social Networking: Class lines and burnout — 6/25/2007 @ 10:42 am